Carmelo's Coat of Arms

Absolutely loved the experience here. The food, service, atmosphere and wine selection was great!

Carmelo's has been our go-to family celebration restaurant for years. I live in a big city, and I travel quite often for work. I would put the quality, service, and atmosphere at Carmelo's up against any where else I've traveled, including NYC, San Francisco, Rome, London, Paris. This restaurant is an absolute gem. If you are anywhere near Niagara Falls or Lewiston, stop by. Worth the drive from Niagara on the Lake or Buffalo as well.

Every meal I have had at Carmelo's has been great. Always fresh menu, always fresh ingredients, always great staff. If you are looking for a wonderful meal in Western New York, put this place at the top of the list.

Cozy Italian restaurant that blends class with value. The interior with wooden rafters and subdued lighting offers an elegant dining experience. The quality of the food was superb. We shared a crispy calamari salad that had a generous portion of tender battered calamari I had the Cacio e Pepe rigatoni, it was delicious. The vanilla bean sorbet and the Tiramisu were both rich and very very good. Our server Ashley provided first-class service.

I love this place! This is where I took my wife on our first date almost 25 years ago. The Owner/Chef is one-of-a-kind with a skill for premium dishes. In a world where everything is speeding up, thank you Carmelo Coat of Arms for slowing us down a bit to enjoy a taste of the good life. Food and Service is AMAZIING!

Dinner at Carmelo's Coat of Arms was fabulous. Everything on the menu is fresh and delicious, showcasing the chef's passion and dedication in each dish. The service is exceptional, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. The location is definitely worth the drive from Buffalo. Highly recommend for a memorable meal!

I stumbled upon this place by accident while I was visiting Niagara Falls. I was told to go to Lewiston and to have dinner at Griffins. While driving there, Carmelo’s Coat of Arms caught my attention and I stopped in. I got the Lumache Alla Vodka and the homemade pasta was hands down the best pasta I have ever had. My waitress Ashley was very friendly and accommodating and she made the experience very enjoyable. If anyone is in the area I would recommend this as a “MUST” try. There are not many places that have great service, great food and a great atmosphere all wrapped up in one place.

Great service, amazing food. Highly recommend for a nice dining experience.